Celebrating Victory Over Prejudice and Hatred: Purim.23

 Purim: Celebrating Victory Over Prejudice and Hatred

By Rabbi Boaz D. Heilman

February 21, 2023

As the holiday of Purim approaches, many of us are busy planning and preparing: There are Purim spiels to write and rehearse; funny and elaborate costumes to create (or purchase); hamantaschen to bake; baskets of goodies to assemble for friends and neighbors; and donations to be made to the needy in our communities. These are only some of the mitzvahs associated with this rich and immensely popular holiday.

The masks we wear on Purim add to the fun and revelry, but they also serve another, more serious function. They remind us that what lies hidden behind all this exuberance and celebration is, in reality, not at all funny

The common saying is, they tried to kill us, they failed, let’s eat. But this condensed version of Jewish history hides much behind the few words. How many times did they not fail to kill us? The hated Haman’s words echo still today, as they have throughout our journeys all over the world, throughout time. It’s Jewish greed that anti-Semites most often point to: “It’s all about the Benjamins,” as US Representative Ilhan Omar declared a few years ago. It’s the dual loyalty—to the host country, yes, but not as much as to ourselves, to other Jews, and to the State of Israel. It’s the excessive power and control that Jews supposedly have in politics, the economy, entertainment and just about every other aspect of life.

There’s hardly a day when we Jews don’t encounter anti-Semitism. And it isn’t only the synagogue massacres and attacks which garner global attention. It’s the daily incidents: the threats; the anti-Semitic myths and propaganda that circulate on the social media; the vile flyers distributed in Jewish neighborhoods and Jewish venues; the ostracizing of Jewish students and desecration of Jewish symbols on college campuses—most recently, in our own backyard, on the campus of the University of Denver. It’s the bullying of children in middle- and high schools, and the physical attacks—the punching, pushing and kicking of visibly identifiable Jews, in broad daylight, on open and public city streets. 

The increasing anxiety and fear felt by Jews in the US today represents a reality that most of us have managed to forget or suppress behind ritualized commemorations like Yom Ha-Shoah or International Holocaust Remembrance Day. Yet what we Jews sense today represents not something that belongs in the past, but rather is a real and present danger. 

Hatred does not come from nowhere. Anti-Semitism is as old as Judaism itself. We can surmise that from Abraham’s flight from his homeland of Haran; we remain witnesses to the slavery and genocide that Pharaoh and the ancient Egyptians carried out. We are reminded of it when we read the Biblical story of Esther. In our own day, though few survivors of the Holocaust still remain, their children and grandchildren still carry the emotional and psychological scars. And we also find these baseless and contemptible accusations in their newest guise: anti-Zionism. Told and retold in story and myth, in theater and the movies, even in seemingly harmless jokes, the Jew has always been equated with evil itself.

That’s not to say that anti-Semitism is a separate hatred in our culture, just one among others. It’s often related to other prejudices, based on nationality, race, color, religion, gender and other lines of separation. That’s why one of the first steps in our struggle against anti-Semitism should be to take a strong stance against any form of hatred and bigotry. As we did during the Civil Rights era of the 60’s, so today too we must present a united front, reaching across all other divides to stand together against all the hate mongers, be they from the right-wing White Supremacists to the so-called Liberal Left.

Because fear and hate don’t stop with us. Directed at anyone who might look or act different, they are symptoms of a pathogen that attacks not only others, but its host as well.

We must never be silent bystanders to hate. There are many organizations that we can turn to for help, from school boards when we realize that our children’s textbooks are filled with misrepresentation of Jewish character or history; to the local police and other, major organizations such as the ADL and the FBI.

Free speech is guaranteed in America, so hate speech per se can’t be censored—but it must not be ignored either. Remaining silent is not an option because words can all all-too-easily turn into violence. Confronting hate speech and engaging all legal means to stop threats and acts of violence are the chief tools we can and must use in our fight against anti-Semitism.

Last month I attended a conference convened by StandWithUs, an organization founded in 2001, in the midst of the Arab murderous wave of terrorism known as the Intifada, as a response to the lies and misinformation that were being spread against Israel and Jews all over the world. I was tremendously impressed by the work this organization does, particularly in the fields of education and law. Its legal staff is thoroughly familiar with everything happening today—not only in our own courts, but also in the United Nations and the International Court of Justice. Its educational work on behalf of global acceptance of the IHRA Working Definition of anti-Semitism has seen great success in universities as well as other national and international institutions. Over the past two decades, StandWithUs has grown and taken on the tough task of fighting anti-Semitism wherever it appears: in the classroom or the workplace, in personal conversation or on social media, on playgrounds or in school hallways. 

Anti-Semitism is the oldest hatred and, along with slavery, the bloodiest and most evil crime against humanity. It’s possible, and quite probable, that anti-Semitism will never disappear. In the Biblical story of Esther, even the king is powerless to change the order he himself had previously issued, to kill all Jews—men, women and children. However, what we do have is the power to stand up and defend ourselves. That is our basic human right, and we must never lose sight of this fact and truth. And that is the deeper lesson of the holiday of Purim.

In the Jewish calendar, we are now in the month of Adar, the month of Purim. The ancient rabbis encouraged us to rejoice during these days. But along with the celebrations, we must also always remember the constant danger that the rejoicing masks. We must never forget that the miracle of our survival is the result of human, not only divine, intervention. It was Mordechai’s teaching, no less than Esther’s conversion from fear to heroism, from naïveté to responsibility, that have made this joyful holiday possible. May Mordechai and Esther always be the model for our own behavior and our own actions in the face of the vile scourge of anti-Semitism, and may our holidays always be a source only of blessings, festivities and joy.

© 2023 by Boaz D. Heilman

To Build a House: Terumah.23

 To Build a House: Terumah

By Rabbi Boaz D. Heilman

February 21, 2023

Former President Jimmy Carter—his unjustified writings about the State of Israel notwithstanding—has set an amazing example for us all. Since leaving office in 1981, the 39th President of the United States has focused not on enriching himself, but rather on promoting human rights throughout the world, earning him a Nobel Peace Prize in 2002.

In the past few years, President Carter’s most notable work was on behalf of Habitat for Humanity. The most remarkable images for which he will be remembered are those where he and his wife, Rosalynn, are seen helping to build homes for the needy.

In this, the former President was following a famous example: that of Moses building the Tabernacle in the Wilderness.

There are, of course, many differences between the humble abodes Habitat provides and the rich and elaborate Tabernacle that Moses created. One could easily be forgiven for asking why God requires such huge quantities of gold, silver and other rich materials for the construction of God’s house. 

Many answers are possible, most of which have to do with our own, human, perception of what is proper and fitting for a structure meant to represent God’s Presence on earth. When we look at cathedrals and temples all over the world, humble isn’t exactly the first word that comes to mind.

Yet the process by which the construction of the Tabernacle was carried out belies the richness and intricacy of the result. For it involved the contribution not only of those who were able to give up a measure of their wealth for the sake of a greater good, but rather the free-will offering of every single Israelite, rich and poor alike. 

Terumah (“Contribution,” Exodus 25:1—27:19), this week’s Torah portion, does not ask for mandatory donations, but rather for free will offerings “from every person whose heart is so moved.”

It wasn’t only gold, silver and expensive dyes and wool that were necessary. Brass and copper would be needed for the nuts and bolts that would hold the entire structure together, as well as for forming the vessels and tools used in the Sacred Service. Those who had nothing material to present could offer other abilities and talents instead—designing, measuring and cutting, weaving and embroidering, and even providing food and water for the workers. 

Unlike other ancient temples, which most often relied on slave labor and heavy taxation, the Tabernacle Moses assembles is a community project. There are no taskmasters. No one is judged by how much or how little they contribute, but rather by the uplift of heart and spirit that they bring to this public endeavor.

The craftsmanship and beauty that characterized the Tabernacle continue to provide inspiration to this day. The seven-branch Menorah has become the most enduring symbol in Jewish art, displayed in many homes and at just about every temple and synagogue. The Ark of the Covenant, today housing the Torah, God’s Word, remains the most beautiful piece of furniture in every Jewish house of worship.

But most of all, the building of the Tabernacle is remembered for the community project that it was, where volunteerism and contribution—be it money, time or effort—counted equally. These are still what it takes to build and maintain communities.

It was his faith that motivated Jimmy Carter to become involved in Habitat for Humanity. It is this same force that moves us today as we carry on the mission with which Moses entrusted us: Creating sacred space for God’s Presence in our midst.

© 2023 by Boaz D. Heilman

Being Better: Mishpatim.23

 Being Better: Mishpatim

By Rabbi Boaz D. Heilman

February 15, 2023

Mishpatim (“Laws,” Exodus 21:1—24:18), this week’s Torah portion, contains more commandments (fifty-three in total) than almost any other portion in the Torah. This list of civil laws presents a pretty dismal view of life 3000 years ago. Never-ending wars, slavery, sexual abuse, thievery and murder are only some of the highlights of civilization back then. In hindsight, we can disagree with some of the laws (and penalties), but it’s important to remember that the primitive conditions under which people lived required some primitive solutions. 

Slavery is a perfect example. Wars were often fought for that exact purpose: Slavery was profitable business, and until the Industrial Revolution, slavery not only supplied essential (and cheap) labor, but often was also an economic necessity. As such, the Torah does not forbid slavery but instead attempts to regulate it, defining the length of servitude and the proper way to treat slaves.

Some of the laws in Mishpatim became archaic and were voided almost as soon as they were written down: “He who strikes his father or his mother shall surely be put to death… And he who curses his father or his mother shall surely be put to death” (Ex. 21:15, 17). 

The commandments that prohibit oppressing the stranger, the widow or the orphan, are succinct and to the point. Others, however, were broadened beyond the specific cases they were originally meant to cover. The case of the “goring ox,” the ongoing and persistent danger presented by an animal not restrained by its owner, is one of the most widely discussed topics in Jewish law texts.

Compassion is a common motif throughout this portion. We must show understanding for the plight of the poor and defenseless, and compassion for animals (including those that belong to an enemy). The famous commandment that is fundamental to kashrut—the Jewish dietary laws— “Do not boil a kid in its mother’s milk” (Ex. 23:19) is understood in this light.

All-too-human tendencies are also discussed in this portion: Bribery “blinds clear vision and distorts the words of the righteous.” Our tendency to go along with the majority—right or wrong—is yet another example of how justice can be perverted. Prejudice and bigotry stand in the way of truth and justice, often forming the basis for laws that masquerade as righteousness, yet are neither right nor legitimate.

It's easy to dismiss this portion as arcane, yet studying it not only hones our sense of right and wrong, it reminds us of what it means to be a human being—prompting us to be caring, loving, compassionate and just, especially in a world that sadly lacks these very qualities.

Mishpatim isn’t only about laws and consequences: It’s a training manual for making us better people.

© 2023 by Boaz D. Heilman

Making Eternity Possible: Yitro.23

 Making Eternity Possible

D’var Torah for Parashat Yitro

By Rabbi Boaz D. Heilman

February 8, 2023

The Revelation at Sinai, God’s Presence and voice presenting the Israelites with the Ten Commandments, is both singular and unique, yet also the most universal moment in human history. Expanding on the opening words, “I Am Adonai your God” the Midrash teaches:

“Rabbi Abahu said in the name of Rabbi Yochanan: When the Holy One Blessed Be He gave the Torah, no bird chirped, no fowl flew, no bull lowed, the angels did not fly, the heavenly seraphim did not say their litany of ‘holy, holy,’ the sea did not agitate, none of the creations spoke; rather, the world was silent, and the voice went out: ‘I am the Lord Your God’ (Exodus Rabbah 29).

As such, one could expect this section of the portion to have its own freestanding place in the Torah. And yet in this week’s Torah portion, Yitro (Jethro, Exodus 18:1—20-23), it appears as part of a larger narrative. The portion opens with Moses’s father-in-law, the Midianite high priest Jethro, coming for a visit. Observing Moses hard at work as sole leader, visionary, judge and arbitrator for the Israelites, Yitro has sage advice: Select respected people to judge the simpler cases; keep only the toughest for yourself. 

This structural organization should have been obvious. Court systems were in place long before Moses. Yet Moses seems ignorant of this obvious solution to his constant state of exhaustion. To his credit, Moses takes Yitro’s advice and implements it. It’s only at this point that the story proceeds with the Ten Commandments.

We can learn much both from Moses’s inability to see what was clear to others, as well as from the juxtaposition of the two topics in this portion. Perhaps it was his love and concern for his people that stirred Moses to be there for every individual. Or (as is more likely for the rest of us) perhaps it was a simple case of micromanaging. We think we can do it all, or that no one else is capable of doing the work as well as we can. 

But the truth that even Moses has to learn is that communities cannot be sustained by one individual. Committees aren’t always the most efficient solution, but the distribution of work is essential for the health of the community. Everyone must feel that they own a part of the project. The feeling of being left out inevitably leads to discontent. Obviously it is important to find the right individual for each task, but in the end everyone has something to contribute—and that’s a huge part in the successful operation of any system, be it legal, social, educational or economic. 

But there is a second lesson to be learned from this portion. Inspiration and application aren’t one and the same thing. As simple and direct as the Ten Commandments may appear at first reading, implementing them isn’t always clear or straightforward. How is one to interpret “murder?” How do we “honor our mother and father?” And what constitutes “observing and keeping the Sabbath?” These may be a fundamental to our legal and moral system, but for any true justice to exist, interpretation of the law is often necessary. This portion both humanizes the law while at the same time giving it structure and process. It’s a delicate balance that requires constant attention. 

Perhaps that’s why it’s only now, with a judicial system all set and ready to go, that the Israelites are finally given the Ten Commandments. Their meaning and intention must be taught and clarified to every member of the community. Only this arrangement—by thousands, hundreds and tens—makes it possible for each of us to have a role in the sacred mission of pursuing justice. 

And maybe that’s why the Midrash explains that when God spoke these Words the entire world was silent. The holiness of Ten Commandments must reach every one of us. No one must be left out of the sacred partnership between God and us. We are all the architects, builders and caretakers of a great, universal Hall of Justice. 

Spirit and body, vision and realization. When both elements combine, the possibilities are endless.

© 2023 by Boaz D. Heilman

 Making Miracles: Beshallach

By Rabbi Boaz D. Heilman

January 31, 2023

Miracles and wonders about in this week’s Torah portion, Beshallach (“At the Time of Setting Free,” Exodus 13:17—17:16). 

First and foremost is the parting of the Red Sea. The image is forceful and eternal, representing God’s power over water and earth, life and death. It is both a moment in history and also symbolic of the survival of the Jewish People through the thousands of years of its existence, overcoming oppression, hatred and bigotry. It has always represented the touchstone of the Jewish faith in a redeeming God.

But faith—even in the face of such miracles—is fickle; doubt pierces faith and often causes it to shatter. And when that happens, trust has to be rebuilt—a long and difficult process. 

There are those for whom faith is, at best, a treacherous path. The conflict between faith and reality causes many of us to become skeptical. We tend to see miracles as no more than fairy tales. Survival and success are attributed to coincidence and luck as much as hard work and cunning. God’s hand becomes obscured by human blood, sweat and tears.

The early rabbis recognized this all-too-human tendency and, to some extent, vindicated it. In explaining the marvel of the parting of the Red Sea, they added a human component to the story. As the Torah describes it, the Sea parts as a result of the partnership between God and Moses: God causes a strong easterly wind to rise just as Moses holds his staff over the waters. In the Midrash, the Rabbis spend considerable time to also relate the fear and doubt of the Israelites, even at that awesome moment. Overcoming this reaction called for an act so heroic that it would set an example for everyone. And so the Rabbis told of the courageous deed of one individual: Nahshon Ben Aminadav. Leader of the tribe of Judah, Nahshon—whether because of despair or hope—leaps into the swirling water. It was at that exact moment, say the Rabbis, that the Sea parted. It was this combined effort—the power of God, the inspiration of Moses and the courage of Nahshon—that combined to make the miracle happen.

In survival, teach the Rabbis, the human component must always be there. We cannot depend on marvels and miracles alone. Much is up to our individual as well as community effort.  

Trust is no simple matter. It has to grow and develop over time. When it is shattered, as all too often happens, it needs to be rebuilt step by step. In Beshallach, as the Israelites begin their journey through the Wilderness, brutal enemies as well as the lack of food and water will challenge the emerging relationship between God and the Israelites. At first, the needs will be seen to by God and Moses. Water will gush from the rock; manna will mysteriously appear each and every morning. God will fight Israel’s battles with its enemies. And with each ensuing challenge and battle, the Israelites grow more confident and stronger, and so does our trust in God.

That’s what makes the parting of the Red Sea an eternal symbol: We believe that God does intervene in nature and history. Our faith in God’s redeeming power is at the heart of our faith. But so is the teaching of Moses—the Torah—which continues inspiring us, giving us direction and purpose. But in the end, this miracle also involves our participation. It is up to each of us to add our effort to the combined thrust of our people. When we overcome our fears and doubts, when we—like Nahshon Ben Aminadav—take the first step forward, we find that miracles can, and do, indeed happen. 

© 2023 by Boaz D. Heilman

The Midnight Hour: Bo.23

 The Midnight Hour: Bo

By Rabbi Boaz D. Heilman

January 24, 2023

Midrash is a body of rabbinic literature going back to the early years of the Common Era. Devoted to complex and sometimes ambiguous issues that come up in the Torah, the Midrash offers commentaries, lore and teachings that fill in gaps in the stories and help us understand better the meaning and intent of the original texts.

As you might expect, there is much material in the Midrash concerning this week’s Torah portion, Bo (“Come In,” Exodus 10:1—13:16).

The very first words of the portion (“Come in unto Pharaoh”) already merit discussion. They are more ominous than earlier directions that God gives Moses. Forceful and even threatening, they indicate the severity and tragedy of what is about to ensue—the last three plagues which God inflicts upon the Egyptians: Locust, Darkness, and the Death of the Firstborn.

But one phrase that occurs later in the portion warrants even more commentary: Va-y’hi ba-chatzi ha-lai-la, (“And it came to pass at midnight,” Ex. 12:29), the time that the Angel of Death descends upon the Egyptians to carry out his terrible mission. The Midrash focuses on the timing that these words imply. Is midnight an exact time, as we would suppose? Or perhaps—like so much else in the Torah—the intent of the word is more abstract, a metaphor that carries wider implication.

That dreadful “night” isn’t only terrible for the Egyptians. For weeks and months now, despite the earlier plagues, Pharaoh has only become more adamant in his refusal to let the Hebrews go. In fact, in anger and frustration, he intensifies their labor and increases their suffering. It is indeed a dark time for all. In the larger perspective of history, this time is the beginning of the end of the ancient Egyptian empire. And as with every such historical event, the suffering is widespread. Pharaoh knows that if he lets the slaves go, his entire system will fall apart. But the harder he tries to hold on, the worse things become. Disease, hunger and disastrous natural events (some would call them supernatural) have been wreaking havoc on his empire and subjects. Huge hail stones containing fire have decimated both crops and livestock; a seeming solar eclipse has just engulfed all Egypt (but not the Hebrews) with pitch darkness. And the worst of all is just about to happen.

This is the “midnight” that the Torah text refers to, the very moment when the night divides in two. For the Egyptians it will become even darker, even more devastating. For the Hebrews however, the second half of the night will bring increasing light. At first it may still seem dark, but Redemption has already begun.

In its telling of the Ten Plagues, the Torah focuses on God’s hand in these wonders and miracles. The Midrash, however, adds yet another element: human involvement. The Midrash cites several other Biblical “nights” (many of which, the Rabbis teach, occurred on the same night as the last Egyptian Plague, the 15th of Nissan). Among these are the night that Abraham rescues his nephew, Lot, from his captors; and the night that Jacob wrestles with the mysterious angel and earns the new name of “Israel.” It is also the very night that Haman meets his downfall, as King Achashverosh orders him to declare publicly Mordechai’s triumph. 

The lesson of the Midrash is that it isn’t always easy to see the light in the “midnight hour,” but that it is there, if only we look forward and bravely take the first steps towards it.

For many of us there have been many dark and terrible times when this teaching provided us with the hope and strength we needed to continue holding on to our faith and mission. It’s a lesson worth preserving.

© 2023 by Boaz D. Heilman

In God’s Time—and Ours: Va’eira.23

 In God’s Time—and Ours: Va’eira.23

By Rabbi Boaz D. Heilman

January 18, 2023

In this week’s Torah portion, Va’eira (“I appeared,” Exodus 6:2—9:35) God inflicts Pharaoh and the Egyptians with the first seven of the Ten Plagues. Each is preceded by Moses’s warning of what’s to come, with the response invariably being “But God hardened Pharaoh’s heart,” as time and again Pharaoh refuses to let the Israelites go.

There are many questions that come out of this portion. How do these plagues happen? Are they a natural process—each resulting from the previous, or are they God’s way of demonstrating superiority over the Egyptian idols? And why do they affect only the Egyptians, not the Israelites? 

And what is the meaning of the phrase, “God hardened Pharaoh’s heart?” Do Pharaoh’s evil decrees reflect his own free choice, or is he being set up by God for the fall that is the inevitable fate of tyrants? 

For me this portion raises yet another question: Why does it take God 400 years to “remember His promise to Abraham” and “take note” of the suffering of his descendants? What does it take to bring God to act? How much suffering is enough?

We don’t know the answer to that one, and sadly we are reminded of this each time we read of another tragedy or disaster that takes the lives of innocent people—men, women and children alike.

In the Torah, 400 years means something like “the fullness of time.” Our human perception of time is based on the sun and the orbit of the earth around it. How does God count? By what set course does God measure Infinity and divide it up into units of days and years?

This unknown factor leads us to only one conclusion: Up until the moment that this unspecified time span has run its course, it’s up to us to fix the wrongs around us. Miracles do happen, but we can’t count on them alone. In Jewish law, miracles cannot serve as precedent. What needs to be fixed now cannot wait for Divine intervention. We can’t just sit there in hope and prayer; it’s up to us to do what needs to be done to rid the world of the evil we see around us.

The Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, whose birthday we just celebrated, whose memory has become enshrined in our calendar as a national holiday, was a righteous man. He was a religious man, a man of faith. But he was also a man of action. He understood the great lesson of Exodus: that human dignity, human freedom, human rights, human life—these cannot wait for God’s intervening hand. The Rev. King took up Moses’s staff, reminding us that it’s up to us to make sure these rights are fully set in law and stone. 

“Fullness of time” is too long to wait when it comes to people suffering. We have seen the consequences of waiting and procrastinating. In ancient days God always appeared just in time, felling tyrants, making miracles happen. Today these miracles are ours to accomplish, step by step, minute by minute, until the “fullness of time” finally arrives, when all the work shall have been accomplished.

© 2023 by Boaz D. Heilman